Skip to content 
Project Background
When Frank called us, he was frustrated. After a major storm hit Houston Texas, he noticed several shingles on his roof were creased and missing granules. Concerned about potential leaks, he filed a claim with his insurance company, hoping the damage would be covered.
After many weeks of waiting to hear back from them, he received disappointing news: the claim was denied.
The insurance adjuster determined that the roof damage was due to normal wear and tear rather than storm-related damage. Frank wasn’t sure whether to accept the decision or seek a second opinion.
What We Found
During our roof inspection, we carefully examined the entire roofing system, including the shingles, flashing, vents, and attic ventilation.
Our findings included:
- General age-related wear and tear throughout the roof
- Granule loss consistent with an aging roof
- Several lifted and creased shingles
- Minor flashing issues around roof penetrations
- No widespread storm-related damage that would justify a full roof replacement claim
While there were a few areas that needed attention, we agreed that the majority of the roof’s condition was due to age rather than a recent storm event.
The Homeowner’s Concern
Like many homeowners, Frank assumed any roof damage discovered after a storm would automatically qualify for insurance coverage.
Unfortunately, insurance policies generally cover sudden and accidental damage caused by a specific event, such as hail or wind. They typically do not cover damage resulting from normal aging, lack of maintenance, or gradual deterioration.
Receiving a claim denial doesn’t always mean the insurance company is wrong, but it also doesn’t mean homeowners should avoid getting a second professional opinion.
Our Recommendations
After reviewing the roof, we explained Frank’s options:
Option 1: Repair the Problem Areas
The roof still had several years of useful life remaining. We recommended making targeted repairs to the damaged shingles, flashing, and roof penetrations to help prevent future leaks.
Option 2: Plan for Future Replacement
Because the roof was approaching the later stages of its lifespan, we advised budgeting for a replacement within the next few years rather than waiting for an emergency leak.
Option 3: Request Additional Documentation
In cases where significant storm damage exists, homeowners may choose to provide additional evidence or request a re-inspection. However, we believe it’s important to be honest and realistic when evaluating damage rather than pursuing claims that are unlikely to be approved.
The Outcome
Frank appreciated having an independent assessment from a roofing contractor who wasn’t simply telling him what he wanted to hear.
Instead of replacing the roof prematurely, he chose to complete the necessary repairs and develop a long-term replacement plan. The repairs addressed the immediate concerns while helping him maximize the remaining life of his roof.
What Homeowners Can Learn
If your roof insurance claim is denied, don’t panic.
A denial doesn’t automatically mean your roof is fine, nor does it automatically mean the insurance company made a mistake.
The best next step is to have a qualified roofing professional perform an independent inspection. An experienced contractor can help determine whether:
- The damage is storm-related
- Repairs are sufficient
- The roof is nearing the end of its service life
- Additional documentation may be needed
Every roof is different, and understanding the true condition of your roof can help you make an informed decision about repairs, replacement, or future planning.
If you’ve recently received a denied roof claim and would like a professional evaluation, our team is happy to provide an honest assessment and explain your options.
