Skip to content 
Project Background
After a recent windstorm, a homeowner in Cypress, Texas contacted Rose Roofing after noticing shingles scattered throughout the yard.
The home was only about 10-12 years old, and the homeowner was surprised to see significant wind damage from a storm that produced wind gusts of approximately 60 mph.
Upon inspection, we discovered that the roof had been built using basic 3-tab shingles, which are commonly installed by builders to keep construction costs down.
Unfortunately, while these shingles may meet minimum building requirements, they often provide less wind resistance and durability compared to architectural shingles.
What We Found
Our inspection revealed several issues:
- Over 50 missing and damaged 3-tab shingles
- Wind-related shingle creasing
- Aging roof components
- Builder-grade roof ventilation
- Lower-quality flashing materials in several areas
The roof had reached a point where repairs would only be a temporary solution.
The homeowner wanted a roofing system that would provide better protection against future storms and reduce the likelihood of repeated repairs.
Why Builders Often Choose Basic Materials
When constructing hundreds of homes, builders are under constant pressure to control costs.
As a result, many production homes are built using materials that meet minimum requirements rather than industry standards.
This can include:
- Basic 3-tab shingles (60mph wind rated shingles)
- Plastic/rubber roof vents
- Poor ventilation materials
- Entry-level underlayment products
These materials aren’t necessarily defective—they simply aren’t designed to provide the same level of performance and longevity as higher-quality roofing systems.
For many homeowners, these differences don’t become apparent until later on, repairs begin to add up.
Our Recommendation
Rather than replacing the damaged roof with another builder-grade system, we recommended upgrading to Owens Corning Duration architectural shingles.
These shingles offer significant advantages over traditional 3-tab shingles, including:
- Enhanced wind resistance (130mph wind rated shingles)
- Greater durability (Class 3 hail resistance. Class 4 hail resistance available in Duration Storm Shingles)
- Improved dimensional appearance (Increases curb appeal)
- Better long-term performance (20+ years longevity)
- Strong manufacturer warranty coverage (Lifetime Platinum Warranty)
The Solution
Rose Roofing performed a complete roof replacement and upgraded several critical components of the roofing system.
The project included:
- Removal of the existing 3-tab shingles
- Installation of new synthetic underlayment
- Replacement of worn flashing components
- Upgraded roof ventilation where needed
- Installation of Owens Corning Duration architectural shingles
Rather than simply replacing shingles, we focused on improving the overall roofing system.
The Outcome
The homeowner now has a roof designed to better withstand the severe weather conditions we frequently experience in Texas.
In addition to improved wind resistance, the upgraded roofing system provides:
- Better long-term durability
- Improved curb appeal
- Enhanced weather protection
- Stronger overall roofing performance
- Greater peace of mind during future storms
The homeowner no longer has to worry about losing shingles every time strong winds move through the area.
The Cheapest Option Isn’t Always the Best Value
This project highlights an important lesson for homeowners.
Whether you’re buying a newly built home or comparing roofing estimates, the lowest price isn’t always the best investment.
A lower price can sometimes mean:
- Lower-grade shingles
- Less durable flashing
- Inadequate ventilation
- Fewer upgraded components
- Shorter expected lifespan
The goal isn’t simply to buy a roof at the lowest cost. The goal is to install a roofing system that protects your home for years to come.
Spending slightly more upfront on quality materials and proper installation can often save thousands of dollars in repairs and premature replacement costs down the road.
What Homeowners Can Learn
If your home has older 3-tab shingles, it’s worth understanding how they compare to today’s architectural roofing systems.
Not all roofs are built the same, and not all roofing estimates include the same materials or workmanship standards.
Before choosing a roofing contractor, ask questions about:
- Shingle quality
- Wind ratings
- Ventilation improvements
- Flashing replacement
- Underlayment upgrades
- Warranty coverage
A roof is one of the most important investments in your home. Choosing quality materials and an experienced installation team can make a significant difference in how your roof performs during the next major storm.
